What is it that separates the Furry fandom from other sub-cultures? It is the art. In fact, art is the foundation of everything we do. Art is the molecular substance that allows our community to exist!
To truly appreciate the depth of this truth, you must recognize just how far it goes. It is not just art that allows our community to exist. It is free expression. Art, done right, is the ability to freely express oneself in a variety of ways, without restriction.
Without free expression, art would not exist. It might be possible to create pictures and text and paintings and costumes without free expression, but those things would be dry, bland, and boring. Art is not artistic when it is regulated, dictated, or controlled. Art is the free expression of the soul. Art is the free expression of emotions through skillful crafting of an idea in a physical medium until it can be conveyed in some form that others can appreciate. Art, but its very nature, originates within the core of an individual and results in a solid state that can be observed by others. The origin is internal, personal, and of the individual.
You know what I am talking about if you have ever been commissioned to create something artistic for someone else. Have you ever noticed how much more difficult it is to be creative when someone else is dictating the details of the project you are working on? Have you ever noticed how difficult it can be to work with another artist when you are the one dictating the details of the project? Artists are notoriously difficult to work with, because art is the free expression of yourself. It can be harnessed for other purposes, but art will always be out of its element when it is being used for anything other than the free expression of the one who is creating it. That is why I always try to allow an artist whom I have commissioned to create the piece I am paying for in a way that affords them the maximum amount of leeway. Yes, I have some details that must be adhered to if it is going achieve the results I am looking for. However, I allow the artist to express my idea “their way”. It is their interpretation of my project.
For art to be good, it must incorporate some level of free expression. Art that is devoid of free expression is dry, stale, boring, and dead.
All this is to say that you, as a member of this community, can never adopt a mentality of regulation when it comes to art. You MUST allow others to create art that is free from dictation, regulation, and “standards”. Whether the content is political or social, art must be unbridled and unburdened of rules. As a community, you must never use policy or public shaming to regulate the art we create.
Are there risks associated with free expression? Yes. There will always be inherent risks in allowing the free expression of ideas in any human society, but the inherent risks of free expression are far less than the inherent risks of strictly regulating “expression” in art.
Calls to restrict, regulate, demonetize, or shame the art that is created by others is anti-furry. Furry, as a community, was built on the idea that you are free to express yourself through your art. The push to remove this freedom from our fandom is a push to remove the cornerstone that our fandom was built on. You cannot have real, true, quality art without free expression and there is no Furry community without real art.
-Sisyphus